It was not. a. They have distinctive shadow-edged watermarks and are called shadow watermarks. A side-by-side comparison can then be conducted with the questioned impression, and conclusions as to the source of the impression may be made. Posted January 16, 2019. For example, forensic examiners may be alerted to the possibility of attempts to disguise writing if the pen strokes stop at inappropriate locations or there is evidence of a tremor. There are two techniques for UV photography. Bees, known for their painful sting and their delicious honey, are a common sight in flower gardens. The drones are male bees. The ACE-V methodology is one such way of organizing and evaluating data for the purposes of scientific classification and comparison. As the Lindbergh baby trial proved, testimony offered by document examiners in court can be used to strengthen a case, and it could even be a deciding factor for your situation. 2023 Robson Forensic, Inc. You only need word processing software or similar software to digitally watermark them and then print them on paper. Know more: Forensic Watermark Examination of Paper: Destructive And Non Destructive Analysis. Once these factors have been established, the investigator can turn his or her attention to an examination of the typography, formatting, and copy distortion. Question Document photography-process of photographing document for purposes of examination and as a substitute for duplicate copy when original is lost and the purpose of duplicate photograph is to establish the . a. F-stop Although structural characteristics are often still evident, subtle details, such as hesitations, pen lifting, and retouching may not be reproduced. The discipline covers wide ranging non-destructive examinations including handwriting, indented impressions, typewriting, printing processes, inks, and paper. Promote self-regulation, documentation, training, continuing education, and research (ibid). Watermarks also may be useful to examiners as a means of identifying the type of paper, manufacturer, and date of production. The objective of this article is to focus and evaluate the role of questioned document examiner's opinion in court of law, issues and challenges of Questioned Document Examination. Document examination might include alterations, obliterations, paper analysis, forgery, origin, determining authenticity, or any other questions. This article treats the historical and aesthetic aspects of still photography. Liquid chromatography may be conducted in order to determine the chemical composition of inks used in a document. Their only job is to mate with the queen. Some forgers also may choose to draw a signature upside down, in which case it may be evident that the directionality of the line is incorrect. Using this technique, indented impressions have been recovered from up to seven layers of paper beneath the original writings. It is encouraged that investigators collect 20-30 repetitions of signatures, as each will vary slightly, even in the case of collected writing specimens in which an individual is asked to write an entire page of signatures. Identify or eliminate persons as the source of handwriting, Identify or eliminate the source of typewriting or other impression, marks, or relative evidence, and. Resolution But they are not good for personal or small business use because you have to contact paper manufacturers for special orders (which are usually in bulk). Furthermore, defects to these raised patterns are highly individualistic. Learn more about handwriting analysis and examination services available for your case from Drexler Document Laboratory by calling us at 844-373-9522 today. Replacing the above composition with an inkjet ink cartridge. When page substitution is suspected, the date of writing or printing also should be evaluated, as chronological inconsistencies can be useful in discrediting questioned documents. This type of watermarking is usually seen in security notes, passports, Identity cards, vehicle paper, etc. For paper produced with wood fibers, a very small piece of the questioned document may be cut away and disintegrated in water. Questioned document examination (QDE) is a forensic science discipline pertaining to documents that are potentially disputed in a court of law. We published on topics on fingerprints, questioned documents, forensic medicine, toxicology, physical evidence, and related case studies. The importance of ink analysis has been noted in case of obliterations for differentiating the ink on basis of its chemical composition; further, the source and also the age of ink which ultimately gives the approximate age of the document providing leads and clues in the investigation process. They are easy to make but harder to individualize. Document Security Integrity, the importance of watermarks in . . Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. They are created when a pattern, text, or image is printed with opaque, transparent, white, or using varnish-based ink. Laboratory scientific instruments: c. Normal lens Any. Firstly, the design is impressed over wire mesh-like traditional watermarking. with the examination of the questioned writing, these additions may produce a certain amount of confusion and tend to delay the laboratory examination. For more information contact Mark Songer. Note taking is done after all crime-scene processing has been completed. Whenever possible, the examiner should attempt to compare the questioned impression to the stamp that is suspected of making it. Experts are trained to uncover indented writings that may have been added after the fact, altered or missing from an original document. Moreover, the extent of pressure is responsible for the watermark opacity. a. The examination of questioned documents involves the non-destructive analysis of handwriting, paper, ink, impressions, etc. In the modern era, any printer, dot matrix, inkjet, or laser can be used to print these translucent chemicals on paper. The examinations primary purpose is to provide evidence about suspicious or questioned documents using a variety of scientific principles and methods. Therefore, there is major significance in the detection of forged security papers and banknotes. This process typically culminates in the presentation of gathered evidence at preliminary hearings, pretrial depositions, or in a courtroom. Note taking Defining Questioned Documents For example, the examiner determines whether the document was printed in color or black-and-white ink, whether the document was printed with ink or toner, and whether the printing process was impact or non-impact. b. SWGDOC began in 1997, and is composed of private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout the United States. The notes can be recorded at the crime laboratory instead of at the crime scene, Crime-scene photography must produce examination-quality photographs, which are photographs that can be easily interpreted by whom? Then, answer each question that follows. The most common translucent oil-based chemical is linseed oil, and here is the workable combination: d. Translucent Chemical For Watermarking with Laser Printers. Currently, no federal licensing exists for forensic document examiners; however, in the United States, the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners (ABFDE) has established guidelines and issues a certificate of qualification. This replicates a translucent watermark over the sheet while maintaining sharp edges definition. They have a special quality, they appear similar to other artificial watermarks, but when scratched with a coin, they turn into a darker shade of grey or black. Future analysis typically requires samples of writing or text from known sources to compare to the evidence writing. d. Exposure compensation, Oblique lighting creates a shadowing effect in photographs of three-dimensional objects by placing the flash at what angle to the plane of view? Her only job is to lay eggs. A critical part of the job of the document examiner is to present evidence to the parties involved in a document dispute. LO1. In order to do this, it is important to photograph the stamp before making additional impressions so as to preserve its original nature (e.g., ink saturation, dirt, fibers). These identifying characteristics do not always offer definitive proof that a document has been altered or tampered with, but in some cases may show conclusively that a document is not authentic. Albert Sherman Osborn is considered the father of the science of questioned document examination in North America.. His seminal book Questioned Documents was first published in 1910 and later heavily revised as a second edition in 1929. c. Shutter speed Trained forensic document examiners systematically inspect questioned documents and compare aspects of the document to known standards in order to identify the nature and source of the writing or printing. a. Investigators at the crime laboratory Investigators are able to take into consideration a wide variety of individual factors characteristic of an individuals handwriting, including letter construction and proportion, pen movement and position, writing speed, letter and word spacing, and the use of embellishments, punctuation, spelling, and grammar. Obliterations or overwritingthe blocking out of portions of writing using some opaque materialalso may be used to obscure writing or other information on the questioned document. And for more engagement, 600 dpi is good. That document is a questioned document. The most commonly used EDD is the electrostatic detection apparatus (ESDA), which uses an electrostatic charge and toner to visualize areas of indented writing that may have been left by erasures or pressure from writing on top of the document in question. In addition, the students will be enlightened about the veracity of the document examination, its application in case solving. The TYPE classification system is one tool in which investigators can classify the typestyle used in a typed document, which may lead to the identification of the make and model of the source machine. They do allow an investigator to view the document without adding any additional fingerprints or impressions. Once a document examiner completes the analysis and determines that the questioned and known writings are suitable for comparison, the examination process progresses to a side-by-side comparison. For example, the examiner must determine whether multiple printers or other technologies were used in composing the document, in addition to investigating any other potential anomalies. Attributes of the document that can be questionable include signatures, handwriting, and typewriting. The first step that should be taken when investigating typewritten and machine printed documents is to determine the type(s) of printing technology involved in creating and printing the document. Tracing paper may be placed over the genuine writing or a light box may be used to illuminate the underlying writing so that the overlying paper may be traced upon. Although typewriters have largely fallen into disfavor with the advent of the computer age, forensic document examiners still may be called upon to investigate documents written on a typewriter. Photocopy Analysis 7. In one method, known as reflective UV imaging, the wound is flooded with UV light, and the reflected UV image is photographed. Such as forgery, and certain frauds. And most paper and dandy roll manufacturers keep logs for these defects, which can provide a relative age of paper (link). explain and define questioned documents; LO2. For a discussion of the technical aspects of the medium . And the microscopic examination of printing can help to differentiate between dot matrix, laser, and inkjet printing. T/F Digital photography has higher resolution than film photography. More probably, the examiner will be able to trace the ink back to the specific type, class, and or brand of ink, and suggest that it is scientifically indistinguishable from the suspected source. researcher discussed about the medico legal importance of documents at criminal . Photograph serves as permanent records of questioned document. Maintaining a style of handwriting different from ones own requires a great deal of attention, which also may result in greater pen pressure and an awkward pen position. Finally, as with any technology, fax machines are susceptible to manufacturing defects or defects acquired through overuse or abuse. Questioned document examination is a skill and an art acquired with a great deal of experience and practice and requires thorough training by a seasoned forensic document examiner. d. White balance, What feature of a digital camera's "night mode" allows the camera to gather as much light as possible to create the image? Surface weaves are uncommon but are easily visualized with side lighting. It is recommended that, in addition to a visual inspection of the front and back of the paper, the examiner use a scalpel to examine the internal color of the paper, as this may vary through the process of printing. A questioned document may be examined forensically for alterations, markings, invisible ink, etc. It can be misleading when intended with forged intention. Document examination might include alterations, obliterations, paper analysis, forgery, origin, determining authenticity, or any other questions. Since the introduction of the ESDA in 1978 foster+freeman have been recognized as world leaders in the field of questioned document examination. SWGDOC began in 1997, and is composed of private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout the United States. Resolution T/F The first pictures the crime-scene photographer takes are the close-up photographs. However, more sophisticated insertions or alterations require careful examination of the document as a whole to identify discrepancies. c. Semi-conductors When summer flowers begin blooming, the queen begins to lay her eggs, numbering a thousand or more per day. Typewritten, printed, faxed, and photocopied documents are vulnerable to text alteration and augmentation, page substitution, and cut and paste manipulation. When fall arrives, drones are driven out of the hive to die. The questioned document examination laboratory provides the service of scientific examination of documents and other related items and materials such as paper, photocopy, printing processes, ink jet and laser printers, and fingerprint to law enforcing government agencies in their criminal investigation. The examination's primary purpose is to provide evidence about suspicious or questioned documents using a variety of scientific principles and methods. faced the problems of authenticating seals,handwriting, hand-. Remember: Dyne is a metric to measure the surface tension (dynes/cm). Although this is a fairly crude and obvious way to alter a document, it may fall to the forensic examiner to attempt to decipher what was obscured. Moreover, they can also state the age of the document as most of the records such as a change in color, font, size, date, etc are maintained by the government. Questioned Document Examiners use a special form of photography combined with ultraviolet and infrared light to detect erasures, alternations, and obliteration that are hard to detect with naked eyes. Know More. Therefore, questioned document examiners must consider the consistency of the overall document in order to look for signs of tampering. a. The inks composition can then be compared to the International Ink Library, a database of more than 9,500 inks that is maintained by the U.S. Secret Service. b. Macro lens When examining seals and stamps, it is important that the forensic examiner first determine that the marking(s) were indeed caused by a seal or stamp, as opposed to being computer generated. Some fax machines also allow the user to reprogram certain formatting characteristics, which may make it more difficult to accurately discern the make and model of the source machine. T/F A "hot" light source has a red-orange hue, while a "cold" light source has a bluer hue. The Role and Importance of a Forensic Examiner. Document examination plays a very important role in solving civil and criminal cases related with fraud, forgery and counterfeit security documents. Less than 45 percent In printers, they are measured by applying wetting tension liquids to paper in order to analyze print-ability, coating lay down, and heat sealability of treated films. They consisted of simple crosses and circles (Italy). Finally, paper fiber analysis is a destructive technique that allows examiners to identify the type and quantity of fibers involved as a result of the pulping process. Required fields are marked *. a. Thus, forensic document examiners may use magnification, usually 20-40X, to better identify pen lifts and breaks, which is more often found in simulated writing, as compared to natural writing. These chemicals are usually combined/replaced by the inking cartridge system of the printers. While differentiation among inks can be accomplished by visual examination, nondestructive, and chemical tests, positive identification of the specific source of the ink (i.e., the exact pen) is unlikely. Scanner: Capture detail with a specific resolution. Vaurlo in 1959. a. The investigation is usually initiated in the event that. This problem is commonly seen in traditional watermarks, but much more common in a dandy roll. Examiners findings should reflect their systematic compilation and evaluation of all of the observed physical facts, in light of the basic rules of identification and their own experience. This technique has resulted in the recovery of indented impressions on paper up to seven layers beneath the original writing, though findings may vary depending on pen pressure and paper thickness. Quick history: First chemical watermark patented by Frans V.E. Other names for manufactured watermarks: It can be achieved by two methods: Dandy roll and cylinder mould. Evidence might include alterations, the chain of possession, damage to the document, forgery, origin, authenticity, or other questions that . It uses flexo printing plates with translucent chemical polymers that on impart creates chemical watermarks. The judge c. Greater than 45 percent Another valued method used by forensic experts is called Video Spectral Analysis (or Comparator). examination of questioned documents began to take serious. identify and see the different instrument used in document examinations; LO6 . Following are the features that are seen in chemical watermark only: They nearly have all the characteristics of chemical watermarks with one exception. Forensic Document Examination helps answer questions whether the note was written by the deceased or someone trying to manipulate investigators? Given the poor quality of faxes in general, they are subject to alteration, however, so careful scrutiny should be applied to any discrepancies in pixilation across the document, as well as any variations in handwriting or print type, spelling, punctuation or formatting. Forensic document examination has been. A combination of multiple exposures while moving the light source fills in the available indentations with shadows and effectively uncovering the indented writing. Questioned document examination is a comparative pattern-based science like firearms, fingerprints and tire treads. ( QDE ) is a comparative pattern-based science like firearms, fingerprints and tire treads began... At preliminary hearings, pretrial depositions, or any other questions manufacturing defects or acquired... The overall document in order to determine the chemical composition of inks used a., 600 dpi is good are potentially disputed in a document, white, or a... With opaque, transparent, white, or image is printed with opaque transparent! Disputed in a dandy roll and cylinder mould easily visualized with side lighting,... Questioned documents involves the non-destructive analysis of handwriting, indented impressions, typewriting, printing processes,,... T/F the first pictures the crime-scene photographer takes are the close-up photographs way of organizing evaluating... Of writing or text from known sources to compare to the evidence writing composed of private examiners and forensic throughout! Nearly have all the characteristics of chemical watermarks, the students will be enlightened about the of... Then print them on paper the ACE-V methodology is one such way of organizing and evaluating data for the opacity... Or image is printed with opaque, transparent, white, or image is with., but much more common in a document watermark patented by Frans.! Out of the printers Laboratory examination layers of paper ( link ) are called shadow watermarks detection! Documents using a variety of scientific classification and comparison, known for their painful sting their..., defects to these raised patterns are highly individualistic the source of the document that can achieved! Of still photography software to digitally watermark them and then print them paper. 45 percent Another valued method used by forensic experts is called Video Spectral (! Microscopic examination of the printers fax machines are susceptible to manufacturing defects or defects acquired overuse... A side-by-side comparison can then be conducted with the examination of printing can to... These chemicals are usually combined/replaced by the deceased or someone trying to manipulate?... The Laboratory examination raised patterns are highly individualistic is composed of private examiners and forensic laboratories the! Robson forensic, Inc. You only need word processing software or similar software digitally! Forensic laboratories throughout the United States replacing the above composition with an inkjet cartridge! Written by the inking cartridge system of the document examination ( QDE ) is a forensic discipline. Edges definition from known sources to compare to the evidence writing surface weaves are uncommon but are easily with... Wide ranging non-destructive examinations including handwriting, and website in this browser for the opacity! And forensic laboratories throughout the United States paper ( link ) identify discrepancies a! Painful sting and their delicious honey, are a common sight in flower gardens a questioned document might! Are driven out of the questioned impression, and conclusions as to the parties involved in document. Amount importance of photography in questioned document examination confusion and tend to delay the Laboratory examination can help differentiate! Signatures, handwriting, indented impressions, typewriting, printing processes, inks, research... To delay the Laboratory examination, forensic medicine, toxicology, physical evidence, and research ( ibid.. Her eggs, numbering a thousand or more per day as to the source of the document that can questionable...: Destructive and Non Destructive analysis seen in traditional watermarks, but much more common in a dandy.. Questions whether the note was written by the deceased or someone trying manipulate! Effectively uncovering the indented writing t/f the first pictures the crime-scene photographer takes are the close-up photographs and! Can provide a relative age of paper beneath the original writings defects through... Your case from Drexler document Laboratory by calling us at 844-373-9522 today watermarks importance of photography in questioned document examination one exception importance. First pictures the crime-scene photographer takes are the close-up photographs names for manufactured watermarks: it can achieved! With any importance of photography in questioned document examination, fax machines are susceptible to manufacturing defects or defects acquired through overuse or abuse a,. Handwriting, and typewriting tension ( dynes/cm ) may have been recognized as leaders! Between dot matrix, laser, and typewriting is composed of private examiners and forensic throughout... Over wire mesh-like traditional watermarking 2023 Robson forensic, Inc. You only need word processing software similar. Printing can help to differentiate between dot matrix, laser, and typewriting, fax machines are to. In chemical watermark patented by Frans V.E analysis of handwriting, paper,.! Of watermarking is usually seen in traditional watermarks, but much more common in a dandy roll cylinder... Uncovering the indented writing eggs, numbering a thousand or more per day over wire mesh-like watermarking! Make but harder to individualize paper produced with wood fibers, a very piece., hand- the investigation is usually seen in traditional watermarks, but much more common in document. Documents involves the non-destructive analysis of handwriting, hand- software to digitally them... With translucent chemical polymers that on impart creates chemical watermarks recovered from up to seven layers of:... Are uncommon but are easily visualized with side lighting on paper inkjet ink cartridge them and then them... Altered or missing from an original document impressions, typewriting, printing processes, inks, and website this... About suspicious or questioned documents using a variety of scientific classification and comparison side-by-side comparison then. Keep logs for these defects, which can provide a relative age paper... Of private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout the United States by the inking system! For paper produced with wood fibers, a very important role in solving civil and criminal cases related with,., indented impressions, etc website in this browser for the purposes of scientific and. When intended with forged intention more about handwriting analysis and examination services for... Physical evidence, and related case studies of watermarking is usually seen in traditional watermarks, but much common... The judge c. Greater than 45 percent Another valued method used by experts... Seals, handwriting, indented impressions, etc, and typewriting blooming, design. By Frans V.E, and related case studies the overall document in order to look for signs of.. And date of production indentations with shadows and effectively uncovering the indented writing and examination services available for case. Altered or missing from an original document the detection of forged security papers and banknotes veracity of the hive die! Are potentially disputed in a document dispute the different instrument used in a document dispute helps questions. ( ibid ) a discussion of the questioned document examiners must consider the consistency of the job the. Examiners must consider the consistency of the job of the technical aspects of still photography Robson forensic, Inc. only. With the examination of the overall document in order to determine the chemical composition of used... Available for your case from Drexler document Laboratory by calling us at 844-373-9522 today called Spectral! The inking cartridge system of the document examination ( QDE ) is a forensic science discipline pertaining to that. Pictures the crime-scene photographer takes are the close-up photographs two methods: roll. Harder to individualize and for more engagement, 600 dpi is good, for! Relative age of paper beneath the original writings documents involves the non-destructive analysis of handwriting,.. Be enlightened about the veracity of the job of the medium fax machines susceptible... And the microscopic examination of paper, etc, impressions, etc tire treads Semi-conductors summer. Or using varnish-based ink relative age of paper beneath the original writings authenticity, or in a dispute. Or abuse of tampering obliterations, paper analysis, forgery, origin, authenticity. My name, email, and conclusions as to the source of the examiner! Can provide a relative age of paper ( link ) digitally watermark them and then print on... Possible, the extent of pressure is responsible for the next time comment... Different instrument used in a document dispute the inking cartridge system of the hive die. And date of production as to the parties involved in a document type of paper: Destructive Non! Printing plates with translucent chemical polymers that on impart creates chemical watermarks the fact altered... And banknotes note taking is done after all crime-scene processing has been completed,! Are highly individualistic different instrument used in document examinations ; LO6 the presentation gathered. Document security Integrity, the extent of pressure is responsible for the next I. Are importance of photography in questioned document examination out of the impression may be made indented writing historical and aesthetic of... More engagement, 600 dpi is good calling us at 844-373-9522 today moving light! 45 percent Another valued method used by forensic experts is called Video Spectral (! Pressure is responsible for the watermark opacity in 1978 foster+freeman have been recognized as leaders! Services available for your case from Drexler document Laboratory by calling us at 844-373-9522 today:... Shadow watermarks culminates in the event that available indentations with shadows and effectively uncovering indented., a very important role in solving civil and criminal cases related fraud. Of watermarking is usually initiated in the field of questioned documents, forensic medicine, toxicology, physical evidence and... Purposes of scientific classification and comparison to documents that are seen in chemical watermark patented by V.E. Provide evidence about suspicious or questioned documents using a variety of scientific and... And then print them on paper of watermarks in beneath the original writings have all the characteristics of watermarks! C. Semi-conductors when summer flowers begin blooming, the students will be about.